Most will dare to say they know what "black" and "white" magick is, right? It is quite easy after all, isn't it?
White is everything that has to do with healing, helping and protection, black with cursing, manipulation, very often the famous love spell. That makes it also quite easy to seperate all the practitioners into white and black warlocks/witches/wizards/whatever. Progressive thinkers may let count "gray" as well, the ones which cannot decide for one of the sides.
So far so good, easy understood and defined. That perspective is solid.... until it get the first cracks and that can happen quite fast.:
- Is it black magick to free a fatally ill person from suffering?
- Was it white magick to forecast an assissnation of Hitler and saving his life though this?
How is it with the abortion of a child which threatens the health of its pregnant mother? Is this healing or some sort of black curse? Would to let this mother give birth to the child be a "white" or a "black" decision?
Or to hurt a molester to prevent rape? Defense or evil attack?
Is to refrain to help someone already black magick? (I mean you harm the person by refraining)
If I give someone energy because he is in bad condition, where do I get this energy from?
The list of the examples is practically endless. It can be summed up as a moral conundrum, a dilemma. Those aren't just difficult to solve in the area of magick, that is how it is on this planet.
Thanks to monotheistic dualism (god and devil, angels and demons, heaven and hell....) we tend to seperate things, to classify them as good or bad. But as the list shows it is not so easy. Nothing is just completly good or evil. Those situations don't only exist in theory or in the area of goddevil if you want to believe in them. As human we will always have to find a way thorugh the middle.
Is seems as the mentiones "gray magicians" do it right, A bit white, a bit black, it becomes gray. But that is not the whole picture. Magick is not simply gray, it is colorful. The dualistic perspective limits one to white, black and maybe some gray intermediates. But if one thinks for a moment one will see that not everything can be classified as black or white. How would that be even possible? Look around, this world is colourful!
I think you all know the saying of the magician and the knife but for the ones who don't know I will repeat it: Magick is like a knife. One can cut bread with it or tear out someones guts. Magick is a
TOOL, the intentions are determined by the one doing the deed. But how it works out one will see mostly afterwards.
Looking around it can be seen that it is very very difficult for many humans to break free from their acquired paradigm, in many people one can find rudimentary remains of it even after decades after the change. But that is no reason to be desperate. At least in my eyes it is this mental fleibility which makes humans great and beautiful.
"Do what you want" (and bear the consequences)
This brings one into a difficult position. How should one act if this handy arrangement of black and white, right and wrong, good and evil don't count as measure anymore?
Luckily we live in a connected world nowadays. We have access to an amazing bunch of worldviews, ideas, perspectives, philosophies.... Look around, live it up, look for ideas to examine. Try to understand why other people think what they think and make up your own mind.
Books, art, photos, theatre,... everything transports a vision of the creator, the author, the componist. Think what might be behind it and where it might come from.
One does not have to like everything but to deal with other ideas keeps the mind agile and flexible and helps us to develope the current worldview even further. (that goes for every worldview, not just the dual ones).
If it goes for the practical decision making there is only one advice I can give: "Do what you want!" (Do what thou Wilt shall be the whole of the Law! is the english original by Aleister Crowley, but it is not only glued on Thelema, it can be used indipendently to express that one is just responsible to oneself and the own moral and conscience, no authority, no state, no parents,...)
There are no "right" or "wrong" decisions. Do what you feel comfortable with ( a small input: Even in accordance to mathematics there are no right or wrong decision strategies. Optimal decisions have to be picked individually for each model. catch word
Game theory).
That is not meant to be a call for raging havoc and disaster. Think about what you are doing and the consequences of the deeds and that you have to bear those consequences after the deed is done if you screw things up.
Who rapes someone has to go to prison, who treats his friends bad risks the friendship, who quarrels with his parents risks the bond. Some of the consequences are inside the borders of what one can bear but some are not. What those are is up to decide for oneself what one can bear and what one cannot bear.
Some final words:
"But white witch Margarete /archangel Gabriel/ this and that homepage says ...."
I don't want to discredit the competence of your hypotehtical aunt Margarete or whoever else but here is the thing:
White lights are probably as common in the esoteric scene as are super dark black magicians. I mean this field is convenient as everybody can claim that he/she is always doing the "right" thing. That can be pretty easy and relaxing but in the end the world doesn't work that way and at least my humble self wouldn't depend my worldview on auntie Margarete. Think your own thoughts, make your own choices and build up your own perspective!
You don't have to like this or that perspective but at least make yourself familiar with it and think about it a little, be it muslim, satanist, christian, hindu or a follower of the flying spaghetti monster.
Ramscha